Browning 725 vs beretta silver pigeon forum. The 686 being a lot cheaper.
Browning 725 vs beretta silver pigeon forum I'm fortunate that Beretta's and Browning's both fit me pretty well and love both platforms! Where are you at in VA? Maybe one of the guys there can let you shoot theirs. Hi all, i have just come back to clay shooting after some 15 years away, when it come to getting my first gun, i had a good look around and i liked the Baretta 682 gold e, i thought i,d go somewhere i could try one before i bought one, i went to ian coleys where i did shoot one, also a SV10, and a Browning 725 S1 so glad i did as the 682 did not suite me, and i really had Well I got shoulder the Browning 725 sporting the other day and did like it but thought the Beretta fit me better and was cheaper so I did it and ordered a Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon I Sporting Shotgun J6869A2, 12 Gauge, 32" barrel. To me, the Citori looks neuvo riche - like the difference in aesthetic between a Porsche 991 and a 964. Members; 185 Report; Share; Posted February 19, 2018. Went with the Pigeon. I love the look of the Beretta 686/682 Gold E, but Miroku have such a good rep. but am open to other It is a lot easier to add another barrel to the Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon I. Trap Shooting Forums. I just got back from Gander Mountain and was able to side by side compare the Citori 725 Field 28" and the Beretta Silver Pigeon 28". It has the adjustable comb and adjustable gracoil. The 525's cast is virtually streight, I have had the cast on mine changed to that more of a beretta as I was sighting down the side of the barrels other wise would have beeen a good time to meet and for you to try the 525 out. Can anyone help me to understand the main differences between the base Silver Pigeon I model vs. It doesn't matter how good a firearm is if it can't be found. Currently shooting a Beretta Silver Pigeon II for my 12 ga sporting gun, and was thinking about just getting the smaller version in the 28 gauge gun, but with a 30" barrel. The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo. The Beretta (or Browning) The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo. Second Media Corp. I don't know, I never shot one. The B-725 is an excellent sporting gun. The Fora platform includes forum software by Browning citori Beretta 686 silver pigeon The 725's are first class, I have a Cynergy CX, Citori CXS, and an old superposed made in Belgium. The Browning 725 and basic Citoris are all great guns. Hell Has Open Borders. More similar to the Cynergy than the 6 and back models. I've previously owned Citori's and like them as well, but there is just something about the fit and finish of the Beretta that gives it a slight edge in my book. Less would be better. The newer model Browning 725 sporting have a lower profile and a slimmer fit than the original Citori so many youth team members shoot the Beretta and Browning equally as well. They had Guerini and Beretta in my range. Currently shooting a 12 Gauge Benelli SBE 2. More miles on the beretta and certainly more wear and repairs needed on it. I currently shoot a beretta silver pigeon iii which I can’t hit the broadside of a barn with and am selling it to buy one of these two. One exception to this is the Silver Pigeon III, my 28/410 Combo is a perfect fit without any fiddling with the comb. The two guns that have caught my eye are the Browning Citori I don't know. I did try a good few other but came back to the Browning I had my selection narrowed down between the Fabarm and a Beretta 687 silver pigeon III for etchens. What would you choose and why Kraai. Everyone will find pluses and minus's to each, I don't think you can go wrong with any of them. 694 is also heavier than the 725, that could be good or bad depending on what you're looking for. While a DT11 is a 'better' gun I prefer the sporty slimness of the 694. Can anyone with a 725 series convince me to stay Browning? As of right now, the Silver Pigeon V is in the lead. Most people told me that the Berettas had more recoil than the Browning. The differences between the 686 SP1 Field model and Sporting model I am looking for a good over/under shotgun for sporting clays tournaments. The aesthetic of the flower pivot pin, engraving, and emphasized joint just looks so much nicer to me than the hidden design of the Browning. PX'd for a Browning, but after shooting that for 8 months, still couldn't shoot it Forums; PW Shop. With that said my youngest son bought a 687 silver pigeon 3 that did have barrel problems that had it shooting 6” low at 13 yards, not good. Seadogrun - I have had the 686 SP1 sporting for about 2 years. The Benelli is interesting, but the Beretta felt better and fit me better. not on website yet list $5340 vs Joel Etchens Beretta 687 silver pigeon 3 combo -Silver Pigeon III Trap combo - 12 gauge, 34" unsingle barrel and 32" over/under. Shooting. Bought the A400 and have been very pleased with it. Repeat after me . I've compared the XT to the 725 and prefer the 725. Also I’m not sure if they make a lefty Currently shooting a Beretta Silver Pigeon II for my 12 ga sporting gun, and was thinking about just getting the smaller version in the 28 gauge gun, but with a 30" barrel. BTW, mine combo is a 687 SP III Sporting and my friends is a 687 Silver Pigeon III Field. This is very true. I love them both. Joined Feb 7, 2023 I also compared a Citori against a Silver Pigeon. 19 seconds; Browning Citori Hunter. The Sorry if this is in wrong place, feel free to move it if it needs it. What's new. I also have the Silver Pigeon III Sporting in 410/28 gauge. There is Silver Pigeon IIIs do have nice wood. I liked the scroll engravings and the aesthetics of their lineup. Beretta; especially as it pertains to elite clay shooting guns - you'd look at the fact that Browning currently doesn't have anything in the lineup like a DT11. correct, the gun will be upland focused, with some very informal clays thrown in. The question is which Beretta should I invest my money in. Cg summit ascent vs browning 725 Pro sport/beretta 694. much Better wood and better finish. For Beretta, look at the White Onyx Sporting, Silver Pigeon Sporting, or SV10 Prevail. Again great advice. Jump to Latest I own both an XT and an etchen 687 silver pigeon II. Both guns are comparable in fit, finish and quality; HOWEVER, their stock dimensions are different thus the old adage if the Three of the five teenagers that shoot skeet with my son shoot 725s. I know this topic has come up before but I‘m down to choosing between a Beretta Silver Pigeon 20 ga 28” barrels or the Browning Citori Hunter 20 ga 28” barrels. Great gun. Browning seems to have a tighter barrel regulation, and tighter amount of acceptable POI than Beretta. Jump to Latest Dark Mode; Light Mode; Menu Log in Forums; PW Shop. Bottom line, they are both good guns, but I see 5 to 10 times as many Beretta autos in sporting clays events as Browning Golds. I was offered the 725 for a very good price. The XT just felt heavy, and not in a good way. Thinking of getting a new shotgun originally wanted a 525 prestige or mk70/mk38 grade 5/6 but had a look at a ceasar guerini summit and maxum today feel really nice but are they as good as Brownings? But if you are comparing this Rizzini to a Silver Pigeon (very basic configuration), then you will find that the Rizzini is a much better value for a gun. I have the 525 sporting for 12 years en now the beretta silver pigeon sporting since a few months HP 17" forceing cone on 692 vs invector Plus, just a liitle longer and most 725 bores are . Had a look at a browning 725 sporter and a beretta silver pigeon I am 50/50 which one to get any one shoot with these guns and how do u get on with them Jump to content Guns & Equipment Forums. Shooting Related Discussions. (I am not saying they aren't Pigeon Watch Ltd. Outdoor Hub, LLC (d/b/a Carbon Media Group), 30800 Telegraph Rd, Suite 1921, Bingham Farms, MI 48025 USA We are considering a Beretta Silver Pigeon I Sporting for her, FORUMS are for ENTERTAINMENT ONLY. I have the Silver Pigeon III and a buddy of mine has the 525 Sporting that I have shot several times. Beretta allows 6" of variance PER BARREL, meaning there can conceivably be 12" between the two and Beretta will consider it "in spec". Stan79 Proactive member. 5 12 I am looking at buying my first over and under gun for shooting primarily skeet and a little 5-stand. That said, I recommend buying the adjustable comb. I will add a 725 eventually. I like the blued receiver and glossy finish on the Crossover I was actually looking for a Beretta gun when I came across the new Browning ( or a variation of the old) will post pictures when i get it. And I know Joel Etchen specs out his 687 Silver Pigeon III Joel Etchen Specials, and Beretta builds them to his specs. The White Onyx Sporting was a price-point model. But felt a little cheaper and i didnt shoot as well with it, where as the 525 felt great and i found i shot a lot better with it. I really like the Beretta Silver Pigeons. They are both excellent guns and I like both, but they are very different in handling and 'feel'. Backpacking/DIY Hunting Equipment. Browning has shown a strong commitment to the 16 dating back to the post-WWII A5 Sweet Sixteen and continuing through the current-production A5 16-gauge. The 686 and the CXS would be new, and the 725 would be gently used. They will all fit and swing a little differently. Especially the 725. I think that the difference in the feel of Browning and Beretta rests with the difference in the factory stock dimensions. Save The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo. The 725 (sporting) w/ 30" barrels weighs in nominally The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo. The Beretta does not fit me well, kicks hard and whacks my cheek like a boxer's jab. I've known some people who switched from Browning Gold to Beretta autos because of better reliability with the Beretta, but I can't think of anyone who has switched from Beretta to Browning. A couple of inertia spring fails, and a break lever cam cracked (twice) and the lockup pins wore out, vs just firing pin replacement on the XT. I've shot them both and I Like them equally as mu Even the current Silver Pigeon I which comes in either sporting or field variants has had 3 different barrel configurations and 3 different choke systems as well as at least 3 different cosmetic grades. I spent some time closing my eyes and In my experience there is a significant difference in how the two fit (either should be able to be fitted to you, but off the rack Beretta fits me better than Browning). New to sport of shooting clays and just bought a Browning 725 Sporting. This is the way that I seemed to have followed, shooting school said that a SP suited me better ,so bought a silver pigeon and the a gold E but seemed not to be able to progress. I'm used to Beretta Silver Pigeon , and have handled 725 before. Personally, I think it's a toss up. Reactions: Nords. The new Browning 725 is my favorite and is kind of designed in between the SP and Citori's as far as handling goes. If you really wanted to make an argument about Browning's O/U's vs. 30" discussion on the TexAgs Outdoors forum I got rid of my Citori 525 for a Silver Pigeon for that exact reason. My choice is between Browning B525 and Beretta Silver Pigeon. The 687, 690, and 692 are more Beretta's competition to the 725. Beretta Silver Pigeon og Browning CitoriFree musik at: bensound. I like the feel of the 725 better than the Beretta SP1. I happened to stop by a high end shop and he was pushing Rizzini, saying I would get more for my money and be farther ahead. Looking at his 725 and my Beretta you can see a difference in both guns. 687 Silver Pigeon Grade V. It was of course a little over priced despite the "going out of business sale". And they are night-and-day different. It also fits me dead on perfect. Join Date We were dead set on replacing my lad's Silver Pigeon 3 20b with a similar 12b but when we tried one vs a Browning 525, the Browning fitted him nicely and the Beretta didn't. I really liked the Beretta, if they had the 30" I would have been tempted. Oct 4, 2022 Forums. And $1000+ will by a lot of boxes of ammo (or at least it did in the good ole days before the ammo shortage). It is very reliable and good looking clay crushing machine. Hopefully Beretta takes cues from the 694 for the DT12. The 725 balances superb as I saw the Browning 725 Sporting model and the Beretta 686 (Silver Pigeon) in a store the other day, and asked to look at both. The Beretta Silver Pigeon and Browning 525 are th Good news is that the Beretta Silver Pigeon III combo in 410/28 gauge I purchased last may has proven to be the smartest gun purchase I've ever made. Jump to Latest DHart, I bought my new Silver Pigeon 1 Sporting for $1814 NIB from Shyda's Gun Shop in Lebanon, PA. I found a SPII 687 with 30 inch, that is what I am looking for, but want to know if it is a better gun quality wise and better for shooting Sporting Browning. The SP1 is very reliable, compared to some of the newer models of Beretta, which have had some teething issues. O/U Help — Browning Citori 725 or Beretta Silver Pigeon? Did some research on this forum and discovered that the overwhelming consensus for a good entry level shotgun is either a Beretta or a Browning. Cheers . I am looking at buying a Beretta Silver P1 sporting in Left hand. I figure to spend 4 grand on this purchase. Then turned to browning fitted me better in the shape of a 725 similar in proportion to a SP ,I have a eye dominant problem so needed an adjustable comb and the low action height Browning Citori 725 Field Beretta Silver Pigeon 1 Weatherby Orion Sporting Benelli Montefeltro Super 90; Gauge: 12 Gauge: 12 Gauge: 12 Gauge: 12 Gauge: Chamber: 3" 3" 3" 3" Barrel length: 28" 28" 28" 28" The Had a look at a browning 725 sporter and a beretta silver pigeon I am 50/50 which one to get any one shoot with these guns and how do u get on with them Jump to content Guns & Equipment I am looking for a good over/under shotgun for sporting clays tournaments. I shoot game and pigeon/vermin. New posts Search forums. My best fitting 12 gauge is a 1992 Browning Sporting Clays Lightning, it shoots exactly where I'm looking. but the Browning 725 mk2 with adjustable comb just feels right as soon as l pick it up, Her i videon, viser og fortæller jeg om forskellen på de to stærke konkurrenter. Beretta silver pigeon 1 left hand sporting. Beretta Silver Pigeon 1 and Beretta Prevail. I own a sp1 in 20ga now that I love, so I am leaning toward the 686 sporting 12. What are your thoughts and pros/cons please. Looked at the Beretta too. Now Well the miroku and the browning are the same gun and in standard form made in the same factory. I shoot with several guys who swear by Beretta and several who swear by Browning. Both in 28ga. For me it comes down to fit, balance, adjustability if needed, etc. But at the end, all this won't make a difference if the gun won't fit you. Point is that it may take some time for you to adapt to shooting the Browning. The newer Beretta basic Sporter, the Silver Pigeon I, has a different barrel set, yet again. And, my best man picked up a 686 Onyx in 28ga. Their model is the standard Beretta Silver Pigeon I (Model #J686FJ8). Hello, I am debating which gun to buy. The beretta sub gauges tend to be too light and whippy for clay target games for me. Step rib, adjustable parallel comb, A forum community dedicated to Trap shooting enthusiasts. It was a perfect fit right out of the box. As a result my 12 and 20 gauge Beretta's have adjustable comb stocks but with my Silver Pigeon III in 410 and 28 gauge out of the box it featured a Browning fit. I am partial to the Beretta because it seems to fit me better. I know they are both good guns, but something tells me that there are plenty of people here with very different opinions. I love my Pigeon for That said, if you plan to shoot other shotgun games, such as skeet, sporting clays, etc. Powered by Invision Community. and want all-around gun - Silver Pigeon is probably the best value for your money. Hi all, i have just come back to clay shooting after some 15 years away, when it come to getting my first gun, i had a good look around and i liked the Baretta 682 gold e, i thought i,d go somewhere i could try one before i bought one, i went to ian coleys where i did shoot one, also a SV10, and a Browning 725 S1 so glad i did as the 682 did not suite me, and i really had I was going to recommend checking at Bass Pro, A few months ago I was in the local one and was able to handle both the Benelli 828U and the Beretta silver Pigeon I Sporting. I looked for a 20ga Browning silver last fall and there were none to be found. Something to do with stock drop, IIRC, but the important bit is one fitted him and the other didn't so we bought the Browning and he shoots well with it. Since I shoot mostly trap , the higher POI would be perfect. I have both the Beretta 686 and the Browning 725 in 20 gauge. I was pretty set on the Browning 525 game gun as it seems to just look that little bit better than the silver pigeon. My preference is a new gun, so I know I'm going to have to pay a premium. By Cumbrian, December 1, 2013 in Guns & Equipment. So do all my Berettas, even White Onyxes. That's my observations. I Shoot both, or at least handle both in the exact configuration you're looking to buy. Looked at the BT99 as well, but I want one I can use for trap as well as field and maybe later skeet etc. Then came along a nice find on armslist of a 32" 725 in brand new condition. I have both. citori 625 feather and while drooling over the browings I noticed a beretta silver Pigeon II, well I trucked on down to the nearest gun shop and tried out damn near every browning and If you're serious about clay shooting competition, you need a proper clay gun - it really will make a difference to your scores, says West Country gunshop ow Bottom line, they are both good guns, but I see 5 to 10 times as many Beretta autos in sporting clays events as Browning Golds. There's The design & feel of the Browning CXS 20 ga. I liked it, but it just didn't fit right. The 686 Silver Pigeon I sporter is a decent clays gun and you should be able to pick up good preloved one for around the £1K mark. In this comprehensive review, we delve into the Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon’s design and build quality, performance and accuracy, features and accessories, reliability and maintenance, and value and competition. Anything SGC, Shotguns Torn between a Beretta Silver Pigeon or a Browning 525. I always think it is a good idea to look at your options, but if you like the 725 you really won't be disappointed Hi, I have decided to buy a new o/u 12 bore. If you are shooting your instructors Cynergy well, definitely check those out as well. Right now you can purchase a brand new SPI for around $1,900 and shoot it until the cows come home before you have problems with it. S. It is a nice gun. Whether you like Hunting, Skeet, Clay Pigeon, Browning Citori CXS or Beretta Silver Pigeon or Beretta 690 Sporting Black? It was between the 725 and 690 for me and I ended up going with the 690 because I found one used and I really prefer the way it swings vs the 725. 95. Even the wood on 725 Field models is typically very nice. The Browning was heavier, and blocky feeling to me. I own both a Note, both of my Beretta 686's have adjustable comb kits installed to get them to Fit. I've handled the Onyx Trap and I will admit to drooling. $7. Something mostly for bird hunting but that I can take to the range from time to time as well. I like it better than the 725, it's really light and the fit for me is Yes, I guess I'm the premier fanboy for the 725 around here, but I just had to find out how it compared to a basic Beretta 12 gauge sporter. Which has a better build quality etc. I have never owned a browning so i started doing a bit of research and have come across issiues with the browning rusting and firing pin issues. However, the Browning is the overwhelming pick of the others in the crew who have tried both. At the time I purchased it I also considered the Browning 725 but the Browning seemed akward and unbalanced to me so I went with the Beretta. I have a few that exchange easily. choices so far are Browning Cynergy or Beretta Silver Pigeon. Any 68x barrel can be made to fit. I was all set to pull the trigger and buy a Browning 725 sporting 30". The better comparison may be the Browning 725 Pro trap to a Beretta 692 X trap. Pigeon Watch Ltd. com Heaven Has Strict Immigration Laws. Ten Point. Japan vs Italy and I can say, both are superb clay target guns!! Allot of the same, but Silver pigeon vs browning 525 Silver pigeon vs browning 525. Just my The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo. If funds are tighter and you can’t comfortably drop the extra $1100 on the 725, the CXS will do the same exact thing for less money. But if you are comparing this Rizzini to a Silver Pigeon (very basic configuration), then you will find that the Rizzini is a much better value for a gun. I'm a Browning guy, but have my eyes on a Beretta Silver Pigeon II Sporting 28Ga. But again, I really like the wood on the "High Grade" 725 Series, Grade V. My last O/U was a silver pigeon and it was dull and I never bonded / got into that gun so I am a little wary of that happening again with a Beretta. All the SP1's are the same price, sporting and field models! They are the mid-priced BMW and Audi of shotguns – solid, reliable, good value, and they'll go on for ever. I've certainly never seen a Mossberg with any decent wood whatsoever. Or you may not even notice a feel difference 686 Silver Pigeon sporting Vs Browning CX. The list includes the Silver Hawk 471, Silver Pigeon offerings, the 682, or the SV10. Beretta 687 Silver Pigeon iii vs Browning Citori 725 Guns & Ammo Discussion Beretta 687 Silver Pigeon iii vs Browning Citori 725. at least of the ones I have seen. Browning me tend to fit me better than berettas but everyone is different. The 525 has a heavier, I still love that Silver Pigeon V and am considering the 20ga. My first gun was a Beretta silver pigeon. What would you choose and why. Because the 725 and Silver Pigeon I aren't direct competitors. Outdoor Hub, LLC (d/b/a The 525 is a "big Browning", like the Miroku and will shoot differently to the more svelte, Silver Pigeon and 725. I did get real close to buying a Beretta 686 silver pigeon though. I would be using it for Quail and Dove hunting and occasional clay shooting. Outdoor Hub, LLC (d/b/a Carbon Media Group), 30800 Telegraph Rd, Suite 1921, Bingham Farms, MI 48025 USA I have both the Beretta 686 and the Browning 725 in 20 gauge. Outdoor Bought the 694 because it was specific for a left handed. Then Had a look at a browning 725 sporter and a beretta silver pigeon I am 50/50 which one to get any one shoot with these guns and how do u get on with them The 725's wood quality approaches the 682; at least in my caseand the many I have seen online. Both great guns but the 725 is specific for trap. Beretta vs Browning. the silver pigeon sporting model? I have researched Beretta's site, forums, etc. Otherwise, I would get something like Browning Citori 725 Trap O/U, such as this: But if you are comparing this Rizzini to a Silver Pigeon (very basic configuration), then you will find that the Rizzini is a much better value for a gun. I have not got to lay my hands on a 725 yet. While Browning never cataloged the Superposed in a 16, the company has reliably made runs of the Citori in 16 bore, coming out with different variations in different years. The 725 20b I've got is certainly marketed as a game gun ("hunter"), and I think it's fair to say a clays specialist wouldn't choose it. Thread starter Panagiotis; Start date Jan 15, 2020; Beretta Men's Silver Pigeon Evo Range Hunting Ambidextrous Vest, Green, Medium NICASHOOTING. I only had mine for about 2000 rounds thru it but the gun was nice enough to make me sell it and my browning 725 sporting to get the 692. It's not bad. , 111 Peter Street, Suite 600 in this thread in this sub-forum in the entire site Advanced Search Cancel My experience is that Browning's fit me perfect and Beretta's are usually a bit low in the comb. The most expensive will be the 471 I was offered an opportunity to buy a Beretta Silver Pigeon III. The 725 swings better for me than my In my experience it seems that shorter / smaller guys seem to prefer the Beretta and taller / larger guys prefer the Browning. I think I've narrowed it down to the Beretta 692 and the Browning B725 Grade 5. It’s much like the 687 but it’s a trap specific gun. Nothing special about it, but it always shoots and ejects. Firearms. Right now I am deciding between the Beretta Silver Pigeon II with 30 inch tubes or the Browning Citori 525 Sporting, also with 30 inch tubes. If you haven't yet, you owe it to yourself to get one in your Join Date: Oct 2008; Posts: 640 #10. Save Share A forum community dedicated to Trap shooting enthusiasts. I've not touched my (beretta) 12 bore for clays since I got the 725 20b though (and i've shot quite a few). I'm between the beretta 686 sporting, browning 725 sporting, and the CG summit. Apparently they only make a few once a year. I don’t know much about the 725 but I know quite a bit about my Beretta. 14 seconds; In summary, there are so many things to like about both of these guns but at the end of the day, I can only choose one. I adjusted the comb when I got it and left the rib alone. From a distance you might be forgiven Shoot both, or at least handle both in the exact configuration you're looking to buy. The Beretta website isn't terribly helpful for me (no pun intended) the pros and cons of the Silver Pigeon I to the Browning 725. Further, both the CXS and 686 would be 32in vs 30in on the 725. Times are good now for me which means I am treading water. I have the Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon in 20 gauge (26" barrel) and just love it. Besides, whether it's a Browning 725 or a Beretta Silver Pigeon Sporting (about the same cost); both are quality guns that will last many shooters most of their lives without being "re-built". Has anyone been able to compare the Beretta Silver Pigeon 1 to the Browning 725 side by side. Thread starter JoostB; Start date Mar 3, 2020; Help Support Clay, Trap, Skeet Shooting Forum: This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, Beretta Men's Silver Pigeon Evo Range Hunting Ambidextrous Vest, Green, Medium NICASHOOTING. What "extras" am I getting buying the Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon instead of a Yildiz Sporting HPS 30 try to sell or trade that Yildiz and see how much you get. When I looked at pricing, Fabarm was cheaper buying a single barrel (either unsingle or O/U) but when buying in a combo, the Beretta was cheaper. Both are very nice guns. Then I went to Orvis to look at there guns. So the question is which beretta to buy. If I was to make a rough comparison it would between the Beretta Silver Pigeon on the 600 series action and the new Prevail and Perennias based on that firm’s new SV10 chassis. Certainly not what one would find on most CG's or Blasers, but very nice. Either Beretta has learned from Browning or I just got lucky but this one fits me perfectly and I didn't have to install an adjustable comb to get that fit. If you are the choosy In looking on the browning website there are like 3 different cynergy classics, is there much of a difference? Is the 2” of barrel worth losing any sleep over? Shoot them both and see which one fits you the best. joeletchenguns. Thanks for the advice. The one that feels right, is the one you need to buy. I would suggest going with the Beretta SPI in 20 GA. But, I ended up with a Browning 725 trap. The 686S is a great sporting clays gun and a mediocre trap gun; the 725 is just the opposite. Guns & Ammo . Next a Browning 725 ProTrap and Beretta 694 Trap w/Fixed Chokes, My second suggestion would be Joel Etchen Signature Silver Pigeon III Combo or O/U. Out of curiosity I did a test mount with a friends Silver Pigeon III 28/410 Combo and it also featured a Browning Fit. Comment. 740 vs Beretta's . I have the browning 28 inch, and want a better gun with longer barrel. Keeping both, although I shoot trap with the 725. I have about 10,000 rounds through it now and no problems of any kind. I know that there is a major difference of feel between the Browning guns and the Beretta, but not too familiar with SKB (505 Sporting and 685 Skeet) and Beretta's (Silver Pigeon II, Black Onyx and 686 Trap) I can at least voice an The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo. Fit and finish between the 686 silver pigeon 1's and the cx brownings will probably be about a horse a piece, with probably an edge to the brownings for the likely hood of nicer lumber used in the stock and fore end. , 24" barrel. However I’d recommend a 686 onyx pro trap. 2 clays in 1. Guns - browning or beretta o/u - I am looking to get an over and under in 12ga for skeet and pheasant. I think the Silver Pigeons and 725's are the best value for the money for anybody look at Browning CX (or CXT if trap is your game) - at $1,600 or so new, it Beretta SP1 vs. I own Beretta's also, so it's not a Beretta vs The fit and finish is above the silver pigeon, unless you want to pay more for a custom one or one of the cabellas special (these are really nice). So my buddy's wife texts me "It's his 40th Mostly because I don't have a 525 that matches the Silver Pigeon spec I’ve got here and vice-versa, but I'm gonna try my best to help you sort of distinguish the main I picked up a Citori CXS, and my buddy picked up a 686 Silver Pigeon. Joel Etchen’s shop is close to my home, here in western Pennsylvania. On paper I slightly prefer the Beretta modified Boss break-action over the Browning underlug, despite it being much thinner than it once was, The two guns that have caught my eye are the Browning Citori 725 Sporting or the Citori Lightning and then the Beretta Silver Pigeon. Menu Log in Register Clay/Trap/Skeet Shooting General Beretta Men's Silver Pigeon Evo Range Hunting Ambidextrous Vest, Green, Medium NICASHOOTING. Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon 28" vs. Save Share The new Browning 725 triggers are NOT true mechanicals, they do have an inertia block to reset the 2'nd sear. Winchester SX-3 in twenty gauge was available (basically same gun as Browning, just different skin). A Citori CX is a very fine gun and at $1000+ cheaper than 725, arguably more bang for the buck if you don’t mind the less fancy wood. Browning CXS or Beretta Silver Pigeon l. They are different in both brands. 04-25-2015, 06:46 AM. Went with the 694. Bought it because it 'felt' nicer in the shop. Members; I shoot game and pigeon/vermin. Then turned to browning fitted me better in the shape of a 725 similar in proportion to a SP ,I have a eye dominant problem so needed an adjustable comb and the low action height It’s worth about 1/3rd of what the 725 is, and I love it just as much. Beretta Silver Pigeon Sporting in 28ga . I have a 687 silver pigeon and I love it. Well after handling both guns today side by side it looks like I am leaning towards the Beretta SPII. Don’t have either but do have 28ga. Hi guys new to the forum, had a question: "The new Beretta Silver Pigeon Sporting does use Optima HP chokes. This Forum; This Topic; More options Find results that contain Any of my search term words; All of my search term words; Find results in Content titles and body; Content titles only; All Activity; Home ; Country Sports ; Guns & Equipment ; I have a Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon I in 20 and 28 that is used for the same purpose you are considering and it works fine. Browning CXS for all around upland game gun. Post Cancel. Beretta O/U's, go to any serious clays shoot and compare the amount of Beretta's Spamming the forum to reach this goal will result in sales access being delayed or removed indefinitely. I bought the 12 gauge, 32" Silver Pigeon I have a 32" 725 Sporting and recently acquired a new 32" Beretta Silver Pigeon Sporting. Joel Etchen Guns has the 2015 Browning Crossover Targets now in stock in 12 gauge in both 30" and 32", comes with 3 Midas chokes Available in regular wood stock or blue laminate. Would a 20 gauge do fine , A forum community dedicated to Shotgun owners and enthusiasts including the Remington, Browning 525 Sporting vs Beretta 687 Silver Pigeon II. From a distance, meanwhile, you might be forgiven for thinking that there was not that much different about the new Browning, but, you would be mistaken. Shoot the one that you can shoot the best! Several people I I consider the two to be equal in quality and design. All of the Browning x25 Sporting models should work for what you want to do, as well as the XS models. It don't look that Beretta Silver Pigeon I will be lighter and faster, Browning CX will be heavier (especially barrels) and slower therefore, I would choose 32" barrels on Beretta and 30" Conclusion: The Citori CXS and Silver Pigeon Are Both Great Shotguns. I Browning 725 owners Browning 725 owners. ** Airguns / FAC / SGC. Outdoor Hub, LLC (d/b/a Carbon IMO the Beretta 686/687 Silver pigeon and SV10 line no better in Quality/workmanship than the 725, to answer your question, the Beretta 391's all felt like a like swinging a swizzle stick. I believe in that price range you owe it to yourself to handle an Onyx!!! Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Hi Paul, I have both the 525 sporter and the silver pigeon 1 game, although in R/H. I've got a Beretta 686S Silver Pigeon and a Browning 725 Trap. I shoot both from time to time as do my kids and a large number of friends and relatives. Because this particular model is built with a Browning Fit. I've shifted my focus to the citori 725 and the silver pigeon. -Beretta 687 Silver Pigeon Sporting 12 gauge 32" barrels A forum community dedicated to Shotgun owners and enthusiasts including the Remington, considering buying an O/U this year. I own several. Well I got shoulder the Browning 725 sporting the other day and did like it but thought the Beretta fit me better and was cheaper so I did it and ordered a Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon I Sporting Shotgun J6869A2, 12 Gauge, 32" barrel. New posts New media New media comments Latest activity. Come join the discussion about Beretta silver pigeon 1 sporter vs browning crossover. It that is a Silver Pigeon III Interested in the Beretta 686 sp1 sporting and the Browning 725 sporting. I'm willing to spend in the Both are great options but one will probably fit you better than the other. Hey guys, As the title suggests, I've currently got a Silver Pigeon 1, but was looking to trade it in for a Cynergy in synthetic. $1695/wood, $1795/Laminate Select Beretta 687 Silver Pigeon 3 Sporting and Field guns now on Closeout! 12 gauge Sporting 30 and 32 inch 20 gauge field 26 and 28 inch. By NorfolkAYA, December 30, 2017 in I prefer Beretta but the Brownings usually have better grade wood. I initially started looking at the Beretta Silver Pigeon I, which is their intro gun. Looking for a 12 gauge. Forums. Same price range; whereas the Cabela is the old 686 Onyx Pro (2002) with Gold E (682) Optima bored barrels and real nice fancy wood. The differences between the 686 SP1 Field model and Sporting model Discussion forum for all things firearms Browning hit a home run with the 725 series. A Browning or Beretta is an equally nice gun. . I have the beretta for sporting which I rarely shoot but I quit selling guns. More . After shooting realized it whacked me in the face due to being a bad fit despite shooting well with it. Jump to Latest The 725 was a vast improvement over previous Citoris of any flavor. I did the repairs myself and the Browning is a lot easier to work on. Regarding the durability of Browning vs. one66stang. Outdoor Hub, LLC (d/b/a Carbon Media Group I own both an XT and an etchen 687 silver pigeon II. If you can try and shoot both HOWEVER, as someone else mentioned already, you should take a look at the Browning Cynergy 28ga first. They don't teach shooting! {RO. Outdoor Hub, LLC (d/b/a Forums. Beretta 686 Siver Pigeon vs Browning Citori Hunter Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon. I'm also interested in the Cenergy or any gun in that price/quality range. For my lessons I am using a Beretta silver pigeon but it was not a full on sporter or game not 100% sure, anyway I have had a look at my local gun shop and have held the Browning B525 30 inch sporter, the gun felt really nice, every time i lifted the gun it came up nicely and didnt have to adjust it to look down the rib, I then held a beretta silver pigeon 1 game 28 as they did I currently shoot a Browning 725 sporting, which I like, but after shooting some adjustable parallel stock guns, I much prefer them for whatever reason when shooting skeet. Around three-quarters of our viewers are Browning or Beretta owners, and they give their guns similar scores for reliability. My oldest son had a 686 in 28 gauge. His has been rusting despite constant upkeep and cleaning. too light. I have on main question about the 686 Silver Pigeon I. Twice the cost of silver pigeon but so glad I went with the 694, plus these guns hold value well so if you are not 100% happy just sell. In the end, the choice between the Browning Citori CXS and Beretta Silver Pigeon is subjective and I have the Silver Pigeon III and a buddy of mine has the 525 Sporting that I have shot several times. I do own a Benelli Montefeltro autoloader. Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon 20ga Summary Shotgun Review: Steve Gould of @TargetFocusedLife gives a summary review of the Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon 20ga Shot Browning 725 Combo vs Beretta 682 E Gold Combo both 34/30. I know Beretta is about $200 to $300 more which is not a problem. The SP1 is a fine gun at about $700 cheaper, but to me the 725 works best. It also I'm looking for a good O/U shotgun. Out of interest, what is it that makes these guns 'better' than 692 or 725. The B725 is the fourth most popular shotgun, behind the Beretta 686 and ahead of the Beretta 687. 732. It much more to add to the above. Try out a Beretta Silver Pigeon III sometime and you are in for a shock. By Rifleman22, December 4 The 725 is often seen as Browning's attempt to build a gun with an Italian gun feel and in my hands they managed it. Pheasant Hunting Discussions. Canuck Hunter Semi 12 MODB left hand. The step up from the 725 would be I have owned several Beretta’s, 682’s, 687’s. and still am a bit confused. I have a beretta 686 and a browning 725. I really did not know how important fit was until I bought my Citori, something felt right when I first held it, then I shot a few thousand rounds through it, and then got a Beretta, it doesn't feel right and doesn't fit right. I've mounted them, and while they are nice my first thoughts are, hmm it doesn't feel as good as the beretta. The 725 will be finished to a slightly higher level and have nicer wood on it. The 725 is near-worthless as a pheasant gun since the barrel has a lot of holes in it. I am wondering what you all think about the Browning Citori xs skeet and the I own both in 30" 12 gauge, a Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon I Sporting and a Browning CXS. I have the 525 sporting for 12 years en now the beretta silver pigeon sporting since a few months Looking at his 725 and my Beretta you can see a difference in both guns. The 725 has a much lower profile. SX4 in SGH 28 3. You need to step up in Beretta to get the same quality of the Rizzini. What are some opinions on which is better? The wood on all of the 725 Sportings I've seen has been extremely nice for a gun in the $2600 range. It shoots where I look. I am between the beretta sp1 sporter and the browning crossover in either a 30 or 32 inch barrel. I've been shooting a neutral cast gun for years and there is a big difference especially with the bfast stock. . I am a big guy and the Brownings just fit me better. I think the CG being the most expensive but a great gun. I shoot 100+ rounds a week The 725 is a different animal all together than the 3, 4, 5 and 625. As stated by several posters, if the Browning fits you the Beretta probably will not--for me the Browning fits. I'm not sold on the Browning 725 either. , 111 Peter Street, Suite 600, Toronto, BROWNING CITORI 725 UNSINGLE TRAP COMBO ADJUSTABLE COMB WITH GRACOIL SYSTEM - Guns Unlimited Newest model has O/U barrel is fully adjustable rib also. It handles beautifully, a quick, well balanced, elegant gun. It's a beautiful gun and I'm I love the new 725 Sporting; Cynergys and CX models. Go with what fits you and you like. I used to have a Browning auto and I am kicking around the idea of buying the GU browning 725 combo (with O/U adjustable rib) or the beretta a400 multitarget. I got a great price. Both are great guns but feel totally different. No problems with any of them. I would also agree that the miroku makes the browning look a little on the Both are great choices, which ever one fits the best is the one I would consider! You have three good options. Great fun to shoot. Beretta 694 vs Browning B725 Beretta 694 vs Browning B725. I believe in that price range you owe it to yourself to handle an Onyx!!! Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk If I were to make a rough comparison, it would be between the Beretta Silver Pigeon on the 600 series action and the new Prevail and Perennia based on that firm’s new SV10 chassis. Is there any way to compare the Beretta Silver Pigeon II 687 to a Browning Citori Golden Clays, for shooting Sporting Clays. I'm kind of a Benelli die-hard, but I choose the Browning 725 when I went looking for and OU. , 111 Peter Street, Suite 600, Toronto, Don’t have either but do have 28ga. Or you can get a custom shop Belgium made B25/Superposed which rivals most of Beretta's high grade guns. However, the "serious" 680-series competition gun was the 682. It's been 11 months and 16,000 rounds and still love it. I have two beretta's an old s56e and a silver pigeon and they both have a very slight side to side movement on the fore end put thousands of cartridges through both with no problems. My first ever O/U was a Miroku and it never missed a beat although not as aesthetically pleasing IMO. The 686 is more comparable to something like the CX, in terms of price, they're at that ~$2k mark. Wouldn't worry unless it gets worse. I still have a 682 for a back up gun and I love it. 1 edit I had my selection narrowed down between the Fabarm and a Beretta 687 silver pigeon III for etchens. Normally I would say pick the 687, however if you want it as a trap gun I’d pick the 725. Will be here next week, can't wait. Outdoor Hub, LLC (d/b/a Carbon The B525 is the second most popular shotgun owned by Fieldsports Channel viewers, behind the Beretta Silver Pigeon. I quite like the Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon, but with the Browning CXS sale price I think the 725 is the more expensive gun on average. Anyone using the Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon I Sporting 28 gauge for informal skeet, sporting clays,etc I went to the patterning board and compared the 3/4oz #9 reloads in the SP1 against my 12 ga Browning 725 with 7/8 oz #9 The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo. They both seemed to fit me and point equally well. So, my first question concerns that 687 All Around you mention. Krieghoff, Browning, Blaser, Benelli, Ljutic, Fausti, Silver Seitz, and Kolar. The silver pigeon also has had consistent ejector Hello and welcome to The Shooting Channel!In every one of our videos, you'll see us wearing the top of the range electronic ear defence from our partner, SWA Browning 725 unsingle Beretta Silver pigeon III Fabram Axis 12 . The 686 being a lot cheaper. My price range has jumped a little bit to in the high 3's. Facebook Twitter youtube Instagram Contact us RSS. Outdoor Hub, LLC (d/b/a Carbon Media Group), 30800 Telegraph Rd, The three guns I am deciding between are a Beretta 686, Browning Citori CXS, and a Citori 725. Looking on opinions on these two. Design and Build Quality. Share B725 is a superb superb gun classy and shoots very very well my mrs now uses mine and my main gun is now a beretta 692 It just fitted me that little bit better than the silver pigeon which I was also looking at as well. www. This of course was is the case with the first year run of Browning 725. When picking my first gun, my budget was in the range of a Browning 525 and Beretta silver pigeon, i think the beretta is a nicer looking gun (prettier). com One exception to this is the Silver Pigeon III, my 28/410 Combo is a perfect fit without any fiddling with the comb. Browning 725 pro sport vs Miroku mk38. About Press Copyright Contact us Creators Advertise Developers Terms Privacy Policy & Safety How YouTube works Test new features NFL Sunday Ticket Press Copyright Search forums. Usually Browning shotguns feel good to me right out of he box. They don't hold their value and there are few lookers. and I prefer the browning. Was looking at the browning 725 field and beretta 686 silver pigeon. Outdoor Hub, LLC (d/b/a Carbon Media Group), I shoot Briwnung deer rifle and Beretta Silver Pidgeon for birds. 725's depending which one you're looking at tend to be upwards of $3-4k, which puts you in the ballpark of the Beretta 694's. Shotgun Clay Shooting (General) Browning 725 Sporting vs Beretta 692 Sporting. rent out Brownings. And the extra can go towards ammo and rounds of clays :) But if you can comfortably spend the money, I would go for the 725. It is a very nice looking gun. For most, it is a matter of personal preference. In OPs situation the extra money won't be for nothing. The 525 has a heavier, bulkier feel to it which some people prefer. I shoot a Silver Pigeon 1, so naturally Beretta's are miles betterbut I did own a 425, which I didn't shoot as well Browning Citori 725 Field Beretta Silver Pigeon 1 Weatherby Orion Sporting Benelli Montefeltro Super 90; Gauge: 12 Gauge: 12 Gauge: 12 Gauge: 12 Gauge: Chamber: 3" 3" 3" 3" Barrel length: 28" 28" 28" 28" The Browning Citori 725 Field is a reliable and high-quality firearm that retains exceptionally tight shot patterns at various Or you can get a custom shop Belgium made B25/Superposed which rivals most of Beretta's high grade guns. Aside from different fit, balance and swing dynamics, I don't think comparing Browning CX (a mid rib gun) and Beretta Silver Browning 725 Sporting vs Beretta 692 Sporting. might feel more in line with what you are currently shooting in 12 vs the Beretta design. The gun will be used for clays only, which of the two would you guys recommend. nlndqbrojvrpeffknkdfvczzdifkwpcxqrtdczxswpjbbgakf